Skip to content

August 3, 2021

Playbook to Bust Bureaucracy

By Mark Schwartz

Note: This post is an abridged adaptation from Mark Schwartz’s The (Delicate) Art of Bureaucracy. Get the book to get the full playbook.

The Way of the Razor

Whales, my friends, have a lot of blubber. If you’re going to do battle with a leviathan, you’ll have to trim some whale fat. Law of nature, sorry.

The Razor is the enforcer of bureaucratic parsimony. It’s wielded by us, Knights of Occam, the bureaucratic equivalent to Six Sigma Black Belts. Bureaucracy is a factory whose output is compliance. A good bureaucracy—like a good factory—is one that uses the least effort and lowest cost to produce its product and can produce it fastest.

The Razor strives for minimal viable compliance— meaning the fewest number of constraints consistent with the company’s situation and risk posture—and strives to achieve its desired controls with as little whale bulk as possible. The Razor trims bloated bureaucracy into lean bureaucracy; ponderous whales into sleek and speedy marlin; trolls into trainers. A visit to the Razor provides a shave and a haircut that costs less than two bits and makes a whale spiffy and fun to swim with. This next set of tactics is from the playbook of the Razor.

  1. Step Out of the Circle: The less risk, the less oversight that’s needed. Only do small projects.
  2. Shrink Everything to Skunk Size: Don’t just make projects smaller—make them smaller in a way that truly reduces risk, because that’s what justifies a simpler oversight process.
  3. Shift Left: Shift left uses guardrails to create a framework within which delivery teams can be creative.
  4. Respect Diminishing Returns: The goal of 100% causes waste and bloat; a simple acknowledgement of diminishing returns was the key to trimming it.
  5. Promote Transparency: Disasters are often public; the costs of guarding against them are not. This difference allows blubbery bureaucracy to flourish, perhaps even incentivizes it.
  6. Apply Lean Techniques: Even within a bureaucratic structure, we can enforce lean practices around waiting times, handoffs, rework, over specification, learning the rules and more.

User’s Guide to the Razor

By all means, look at your value streams and see where bureaucracy is adding to your lead times! Calculate its cost, in lead time and dollars, then find ways to reduce it while still mitigating the same risks and achieving the same results. Keep in mind:

  • The Razor reduces your costs, sometimes significantly, as a byproduct of reducing your lead times.
  • If you have a choice between reducing productive activities and reducing watching or wasteful (in other words non-lean) compliance efforts, think carefully . . .
  • You can’t just shave once and be done with it. You gotta do it every day. Under the blubber there may be more blubber.
  • Razoring is the easiest aspect of digital transformation to sell to others. Who doesn’t want to eliminate waste? The CEO and CFO, in particular, are likely to be supportive if you show them data.

Next, we’ll look at the Way of the Sumo Wrestler…

- About The Authors
Avatar photo

Mark Schwartz

Mark Schwartz is an iconoclastic CIO and a playful crafter of ideas, an inveterate purveyor of lucubratory prose. He has been an IT leader in organizations small and large, public, private, and nonprofit. As an Enterprise Strategist for Amazon Web Services, he uses his CIO experience to bring strategies to enterprises or enterprises to strategies, and bring both to the cloud. As the CIO of US Citizenship and Immigration Services, he provoked the federal government into adopting Agile and DevOps practices. He is pretty sure that when he was the CIO of Intrax Cultural Exchange he was the first person ever to use business intelligence and supply chain analytics to place au pairs with the right host families. Mark speaks frequently on innovation, bureaucratic implications of DevOps, and using Agile processes in low-trust environments. With a BS in computer science from Yale, a master’s in philosophy from Yale, and an MBA from Wharton, Mark is either an expert on the business value of IT or else he just thinks about it a lot.

Follow Mark on Social Media

1 Comment

  • Anne Davey Koomans Aug 4, 2021 9:40 pm

    I completely agree with what you have written. I hope this post could reach more people as this was truly an interesting post.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.



Avatar photo

Mark Schwartz

Jump to Section

    More Like This

    The Road Ahead: Emerging Trends and Future Directions for Enterprise GenAI
    By Leah Brown

    As enterprises build and scale their GenAI implementations, forward-thinking leaders are already anticipating the…

    Read Article
    Unbundling the Enterprise: How API Strategies Can Transform the Public Sector
    By Leah Brown

    The Public Sector's Unique Challenge Government agencies face a fundamental problem: Imagine if you…

    Read Article
    Implementing at Scale: Strategies for Enterprise-Wide GenAI Adoption
    By Leah Brown

    Moving from isolated pilots to enterprise-wide GenAI implementation requires thoughtful strategies that balance innovation…

    Read Article
    The Physics of Flow: How the Constructal Law Can Revolutionize Product Development
    By Leah Brown

    In product development, the quest for better flow has been a constant for nearly…

    Read Article